For most travelers, polycarbonate is the safest all-round hard shell: usually light and tougher than ABS. ABS is typically the cheapest and can be very light, but it is generally more prone to cracking. Aluminum is strong and long-lasting but tends to be heavier, dents and costs more.
ABS
ABS is a common, inexpensive thermoplastic. It makes light, rigid shells and can be molded into many colors and finishes. The usual downside is that ABS is more brittle than polycarbonate and may crack under a hard impact or in cold conditions. Cheap ABS bags in particular can feel thin. It can be a sensible choice for occasional trips or a tight budget.
Polycarbonate
Polycarbonate is a tougher plastic that tends to flex and bounce back instead of cracking. It is commonly used on mid-range and premium hardside suitcases and is often a little heavier than ABS, though thinner designs can be very light. The shell can still scratch and scuff, and quality varies by brand and thickness, so a “polycarbonate” label alone does not guarantee a strong bag.
Blends and polypropylene
Many brands use polycarbonate and ABS blends to balance cost, weight and strength. Some use polypropylene, which is flexible and light and often resists impact well, though it may feel less rigid. Check the manufacturer’s description, and treat marketing names with caution.
Aluminum
Aluminum suitcases, the best-known being from Rimowa, are rigid and strong, and they can last for years. They tend to be heavier and more expensive than plastic shells, and they dent instead of flexing back, though many owners view dents and scratches as part of the look. Repairs can be possible but may be costly, and the metal may conduct more heat or cold than plastic. Weight is a real consideration, since the bag uses up part of your allowance; see best lightweight travel suitcases.
At a glance
- Weight: ABS is often lightest, polycarbonate is similar or slightly heavier, aluminum is generally heaviest.
- Impact resistance: Polycarbonate usually flexes and recovers; ABS is more likely to crack; aluminum resists cracking but can dent.
- Price: ABS is usually cheapest, polycarbonate sits in the middle and aluminum is usually the most expensive.
- Looks over time: Plastic shows scratches; aluminum dents and develops patina.
What else matters
The shell is only part of a good bag. Wheels, handles, zippers or latches, and the warranty often decide how long a suitcase lasts. See spinner vs. two-wheel luggage and what to avoid when buying luggage.
Which to buy
- Budget or occasional travel: ABS, or an ABS blend from a brand with a reasonable warranty.
- Frequent flyers who want a balance: Polycarbonate.
- Style and long-term ownership, with a bigger budget: Aluminum.
If you are unsure whether to go hard at all, read is it better to fly with hard or soft luggage. For international trips, see the best luggage for international travel.